Is It Worth Stanning a Temporary K-Pop Group? (Part 2)

Here’s why some fans stay loyal despite a group’s short promotion cycle.

In my last article, I questioned whether it’s worth supporting temporary survival groups in K-pop. For some fans, stanning a temporary group can feel like signing up for heartbreak. The clock starts ticking the moment the lineup is confirmed. You know it won’t last but you still dive in headfirst.

So why do fans keep investing in groups that are guaranteed to end?

The Thrill of the Now

Temporary groups move fast. They have to since they’re only promoting for a short time. Comebacks, fan meetings, music shows, concerts are all packed into a tight window.

There’s a shared understanding between idols and fans that this won’t last forever. That makes every release feel special and every moment counts. The fact that everything is moving at such a fast pace can be intense and even addictive.

The Fandom Starts to Feels Like Family

Fans of survival groups often form incredibly tight-knit communities. When everyone knows the group has an expiration date, there’s a stronger sense of “us.” You rally for votes, stream like it’s your job, and plan fan projects with strangers that are starting to feel like friends.

It’s less about being a fan and more about living through a shared moment. And that sense of unity doesn’t dissolve when the group does. Many fans stay in touch, transition together to new fandoms, or continue supporting individual members as they re-debut, go solo, etc. The bond fans form with one another doesn’t end when the contract does.

Watching Growth in Real Time

Survival shows often tell a story about the people competing on these shows. You have trainees who came close to debuting in a group but never made the cut. Idols who’ve bounced around different groups throughout their career or they’re hoping to save their group from disbandment by attracting new fans.

You watch these people improve, gain confidence, and evolve as performers. When your bias gets eliminated or barely scrapes into the debut lineup, it hits you in the gut. And when they succeed, you’re celebrating the growth you witnessed from day one.

Yes that sounds very parasocial but it’s real to the people living it.

It’s Not Really the End

It’s easy to assume that with temporary groups, everything stops after disbandment. In reality, that’s often when the next chapter begins.

Look at I.O.I. After their disbandment, Chungha became a top soloist. Sejeong transitioned into acting. Weki Meki and gugudan debuted with I.O.I members, and their fans followed.

Same with IZ*ONE. Wonyoung and Yujin debuted in IVE. Sakura and Chaewon formed LE SSERAFIM. Their fans followed these idols as they transitioned into the next phase of their careers. Sometimes stanning a temporary group means being there at the start of something special.

What the Industry Can Do Better

While the fan experience can be beautiful, the system still has its flaws. To make temporary groups more sustainable for both fans and idols, the K-pop industry needs to rethink a few things.

Create Hybrid Models

Groups like Kep1er or X1 (had they lasted longer) show there’s potential in hybrid contracts. It’s when groups debut with a fixed term but allow for extensions if successful. That gives fans hope for continuation and gives members some career stability.

Offer Post-Group Plans

Post-disbandment support can go a long way. Whether it’s special reunion projects, digital singles, or anniversary livestreams, fans appreciate knowing their favorite group still lives on.

Promote Individual Growth

Let idols build solo identities while promoting their group. Give them OSTs, sub-units, variety appearances. This builds career foundations for later and makes fans more likely to stay with them post-group.

Make the End a Celebration

Farewell concerts, a final comeback that gives a feeling of closure to the group and the members, fan meetings. Ending a group doesn’t have to feel like a loss if it’s framed as a celebration of what was achieved.

Stanning a temporary group doesn’t have to be a gamble. When done right, it’s a fast-burning, unforgettable spark that can lead to something more.

It gives fans a chance to be part of something that will never happen again. For idols, it’s often a launchpad towards a long and successful career.

With smarter planning, transparency, and respect for both artists and fans, the K-pop industry can turn these short-lived projects into moments that are worth investing in over and over again.

You May Also Like