Detective Comics #1115: Clark Kent is Charged with Murder?!

Clark Kent is arrested in Detective Comics #1115
After Smallville mayor’s daughter is killed, Clark Kent becomes the prime suspect. Batman takes on the case but can he prove Clark’s innocence?

Clark Kent is without a doubt one of the, if not the kindest, friendliest, down-to-earth guys you’d ever find in comics. It’s hard to imagine the civilian identity of Superman hurting a fly. And yet, in Detective Comics #1115, he’s been accused of murder. The new six-issue story arc “Clark Kent: Murderer,” written by Tom Taylor with art and colors by Mikel Janín (and letters by Wes Abbott), follows Batman as he investigates a crime Superman can’t even deny committing.

If you’re a longtime DC Comics fan, that title probably rings a bell. Back in 2002, Batman went through something similar in “Bruce Wayne: Murderer?” where he was framed for killing his girlfriend. Now, Taylor and Janín are flipping the script for their final run on Detective Comics. Coming right after their “Flight” story with Green Arrow and Black Canary and the “Bad Seeds” crossover, this new mystery puts the friendship between Batman and Superman to the ultimate test.

A Deadly Night in Smallville

It’s a dark night at the Smallville Crows football stadium, the small, rural town where Clark Kent grew up. A woman wearing glasses and a purple coat is standing on the turf with another person, though they’re out of view.

“What are you–?” The woman doesn’t get to finish her question when she sees that mystery person doing something that makes her panic. “Clark!” she yells but it’s too late. BANG! A shotgun blasts, and the scene cuts straight to the stadium scoreboard with another loud BANG.

Esme Brennan is shot dead in Detective Comics #1115

Three days later in Metropolis, Superman stops to help a broken-down school bus with a stuck lug nut. He flies the bus to a museum so the kids don’t miss their field trip and even teaches one of them how to use a breaker bar to fix the tire.

Superman hears the news of Esme's murder

That wholesome moment comes to an abrupt halt when Superman overhears a breaking news report from a nearby radio. The body of Esme Brennan, the daughter of Smallville’s mayor Dorothy Brennan, was found in a field outside Smallville. The local sheriff has issued an arrest warrant for a prominent Metropolis reporter Clark Kent, who went to high school with Esme. Trying to keep his calm demeanor, Superman cuts his time with the kids short and flies straight home.

Putting Away the Cape

Back at their apartment, Lois Lane pleads with Clark to stay away from the cops so they can start their own investigation and clear his name. Clark refuses. “This isn’t about Superman,” he tells her, swapping his blue and red suit for a plain red flannel shirt. If Clark Kent is accused of a crime, Clark Kent is going to face it.

Before he leaves, he gets a call from “B” (Batman). Clark ignores it, kisses Lois goodbye, and takes off. Seconds later, Batman hacks straight through Lois’s unanswered phone demanding to know where Clark went. He doesn’t really need an answer, though. Both of them already know.

Batman calls Lois Lane in Detective Comics #1115

Clark flies to Smallville and walks straight into the Sheriff’s Office. A nervous young deputy named Jamie draws his gun and shouts at Clark to put his hands up. Fortunately, the local sheriff, Larry, is an old friend of Clark’s. Larry sends the shaken deputy on a break and explains that Jamie was the one who found Esme’s body that morning. He apologizes as he puts Clark in handcuffs.

Batman Takes the Case

Batman meets with the Justice League in Detective Comics #1115

Meanwhile, Batman holds a tense meeting with the Justice League, including Wonder Woman, the Flash, Black Canary, Green Arrow and Black Lightning. The Flash worries what could happen if someone like Darkseid attacks while Superman is sitting in a jail cell. Black Lightning points out that Clark is principled, not stubborn. He’ll step up if the world is in danger. When Black Canary asks how the League can help, Batman shuts them down. “For now, you don’t.” Instead, the World’s Greatest Detective will handle this case by himself.

Six miles north of Smallville, Batman inspects the cornfield where Esme was found. Because there are no tire skid marks on the road, he figures her body was tossed from a moving car. Using his high-tech lenses, Batman spots tiny clues the local police missed: fibers from a plastic farm feed sack, rubber crumbs, and synthetic turf. Turkey vultures led locals to the body, meaning Esme had already been dead for days before anyone noticed she was missing.

Batman investigates the evidence against Clark in Detective Comics #1115

Next, Batman sneaks into the local coroner’s office to examine Esme’s body. The turf and feed sack fibers match the field, proving she was killed on a football field and dumped in a feed sack. One troubling piece of evidence is a blood-stained Daily Planet business card belonging to Clark Kent. Batman uses Esme’s face to unlock her smartphone (though he notes how the gunshot came dangerously close to ruining her face) and downloads all her data. Her very last phone call was to Clark Kent.

Did Clark Kent Murder Esme?

Back at the jail, Sheriff Larry brings Clark some blankets for the night. Clark asks how Mayor Brennan is holding up, and Larry admits he was there when she had to identify her daughter’s body. “I can’t talk about the case,” Larry tells Clark in a way that makes it clear the whole thing is just too painful to discuss. At 10:00 PM, Larry turns off the lights and heads out. “If you need anything, just wave to the camera,” Larry says.

Batman meets with Clark Kent in his cell

As soon as Clark is alone in the dark, Batman steps out of the shadows. He’s disrupting all audio and video feeds so nobody can listen in. Batman tells Clark that Esme was shot twice with a shotgun, once in the chest while trying to shield herself with her right hand, and once in the head. Clark admits he already knows, since his super-vision lets him see her body in the morgue down the hall.

Clark states that nobody will ask him the most important question and pretty much demands that his best friend ask him. So, Batman looks him in the eye and says “Clark Kent. Did you murder Esme Brennan?”

After a heavy silence, Clark gives a chilling answer. “I don’t know.”

Was Clark framed by someone who knows his secret identity? Did the real mastermind use mind control or magic to force Clark to kill someone in cold blood? Whatever happens on that football field, Batman has his work cut out for him if he wants to clear a friend who can’t even vouch for himself.​

You May Also Like